Photograph by Loren Bliss copyright 2011.
*
VISUALS
Portrait of a Knoxville woman, 1967. This is one of a series of photographs I made in East Tennesse while visiting there with my wife Adrienne shortly after we were married. The print, on the long-discontinued, forever lamented and never-to-be-equaled DuPont Varilure, is 44 years old; it survived the fire because it was part of my working portfolio. Tri-X at 1200 in Diafine; Canon VT with the 35mm f/2 screw-mount Summicron, other data lost or forgotten.
*****
EXTRA: THOUGHTS ON A SPECIAL OCCASION
The hit on Osama bin Laden would seem to have checkmated the Republicans. Thus, finally, there are no political obstacles in the way of President Obama becoming the personification of "change we can believe in" – the president for whom we voted. Will he? I surely hope so, but I gravely doubt it. The obstacles to change are not our pseudo-partisan politics; the barriers are entirely economic – matters of class-struggle actually – the fact Obama, the Democrats and the Republicans are all wholly owned subsidiaries of Wall Street and Big Business, with the Republicans functioning as a Machiavellian noise machine to provide Obama the cover he needs for his betrayals.
***
Just as many expatriates from the States were prompted by the attack on Pearl Harbor to once again acknowledge their U.S. citizenship, so did the atrocities of 9/11 prove to this exiled Manhattanite there is no such thing as a “former” New Yorker.
I was up unusually early the morning of 9/11 because a friend and I were going grouse hunting – the forest-grouse season in Washington state opens on 1 September and the all-white meat is one of Mother Nature's delicacies. My friend had the early morning news on the idiot box to accompany his coffee, and by the time I walked into his living room, the first attack had already happened. I dismissed the initial strike as a terrible accident – I could hardly forget the B-25 that had flown into the Empire State Building in 1945 – but then the second plane hit the second tower, and I knew we were under attack.
Though I left the City in late 1986, my first reaction after horror and outrage was a strong and surprising impulse to return home, and my next emotion an astonishingly deep guilt that I would not – a guilt no doubt partly expressed by my telephone call later that day to confirm the survival of my former wife and dear friend Adrienne. Meanwhile I was quietly damning myself for being Here and not There – There in the City where at the very least I could record the valiant struggles of my fellow New Yorkers and perhaps even provide some small but useful assistance beyond my obligations as an archivist.
Skeptics who jeer at the notion of a journalist providing “some small but useful assistance” should note the ghoulish, morally imbecilic non-involvement now attributed to journalists in general was originally a defining characteristic of television personnel only. (The fact I avoid saying “television journalists” is a declaration of my recognition “journalism” and “television” are mutually exclusive terms.) Print journalists – real journalists (self very much included) – often provided initial aid to police and paramedics, performing basic duties like setting out road flares to mark accident scenes or helping usher gawking crowds away from danger or even rendering basic first aid. In the old days – when Big Business ownership was limited to television, only the televoids were required to be lurking ghouls. For the rest of us, getting the picture or the story or both didn't mean we just stood and watched, especially when we were first on the scene. Of course it's different today: everywhere in Ruling Class Media, “corporate ghoul” is now part of the job description. But amongst my generation of reporters and photographers, the impulse to render aid when necessary had not yet been suppressed by management.
Which brings us back to 9/11. Ironically, when the World Trade Center was being built, I was among its many detractors. (Construction began in 1966, and that only after raging controversy.) Once it was erected, I like many other aesthetically minded New Yorkers thought the Twin Towers ruined the formerly-perfect Manhattan skyline, the structures giving the island a jarringly stern-heavy look, as if it were sinking into the harbor, Battery Park first. But when bin Laden's terrorists attacked the towers and turned them into the tomb of 2,792 women, men and – let us not forget – children, it felt as if my own neighborhood had been bombed, and my eyes teared with impotent fury.
Thus my applause for the bin Laden hit. And a hit it clearly was, its Mafiosi spare-the-wives-and-children efficiency surely appropriate vengeance for an attack on the City not just boastfully famous as the cultural center of all Westernesse but also quietly infamous as the national headquarters of Cosa Nostra.
Nor will I apologize for applauding. Truth is, the whining, sniveling and hand-wringing of critics – the wailing and gnashing of teeth whether from Left or Right – disgusts me exactly as I am disgusted by the revisionist “historians” who now so disingenuously lament our response to Axis Japan's raid on Pearl Harbor.
The fact is bin Laden attacked the City that is my birthplace and original home, the realm that shaped my consciousness and nurtured my intellect and is thus quite literally my Motherland. My only regret is the murderer's end was so quick and clean: Osama bin Laden should have been paraded in chains through the streets of the Five Boroughs, introduced to Madam la Guillotine before a crowd of 100,000 in the Sheep Meadow of Central Park and his severed head then pickled in a bell jar – to be brought out for public display at the former World Trade Center site every 9/11 hereafter.
*****
NULLE BASTARDO
Thanks to Truthout, a follow-up on the Tucson Rebellion (with pictures): The Tucson school board was to begin eliminating Mexican-American Studies (MAS), but before the board arrived for its 26 April meeting, nine students and alumni of Tucson schools seized the board members' seats, sat and chained themselves together to oppose this newest manifestation of Arizona thought control. A security guard grabbed the two young women leading the charge, but they struggled free and shackled themselves with the others.
Republican Tom Horn, the former state superintendent of schools who last year won election as Arizona attorney general after a campaign of Nazi-style hate-mongering, has sought for years to suppress ethnic studies and has made MAS his primary target. Horn claims “the program promotes anti-American ideas and radicalizes students of color by teaching them that they are members of an oppressed minority.”
Here's a report the Ruling Class doesn't want us to read, with full details including the background of the fight:
http://www.truthout.org/education-action-inside-arizona-ethnic-studies-battle/1304619698
***
Foreclosure reveals the true savagery of capitalism: Evicting homeowners and their families into inescapable poverty and often-permanent homelessness is part of “a broader set of interlocking efforts to exploit those hardest hit by the endless economic hard times...There is no underground conspiracy. The facts are in plain sight...If the public ever gets a complete picture of the personal, financial, and legal assault on citizens at their most vulnerable, the outrage will be endless.” Another story the Ruling Class Media routinely suppresses:
http://www.truthout.org/beyond-foreclosuregate-it-gets-uglier/1304731308
***
Americans United fights theocracy by protesting the National Day of Prayer: “Americans don’t need a federal government directive to tell them when, whether and how to pray,” said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United. “There are many things that government does well, but managing Americans’ religious lives isn’t one of them.”
Given the intimate connection between theocracy and capitalism – capitalists as tyrants, religious authorities as thought police – we should all join Americans United for Separation of Church and State. It is far more focused than the American Civil Liberties Union, and unlike the ACLU, it did not betray us all by arguing for Citizens United, the supreme court decision that forever destroyed the (few) remnants of U.S. constitutional democracy.
http://www.au.org/media/press-releases/archives/2011/05/congressionally-mandated.html
***
Christian bullies attack anti-bullying efforts: as states and school districts work to stem a tide of fundamentalist-provoked anti-gay bullying in American public schools, the JesuNazis have launched a counter-offensive to ban programs that seek to protect LGBT youth from homophobic thugs. People for the American Way, a group well worth supporting, has the details in an investigative report entitled "Big Bullies: How the Religious Right is Trying to Make Schools Safe for Bullies and Dangerous for Gay Kids":
http://site.pfaw.org/site/MessageViewer?dlv_id=26781&em_id=20181.0
***
Capitalism's War on Working-Class Youth (a Seattle perspective): Seattle politicians of “both” parties – the Teabagging GOPorkers and their always-compliant DemocRat enablers – are eliminating government-funded programs for children-in-crisis despite the fact such programs “are one of society's best bargains.” University of Chicago professor James Heckman, awarded the 2000 Nobel Prize in economics, “calculates that the rate of return on these investments, 'seen in a purely economic setting, range from 7-10 percent. As a benchmark, the historical return on the stock market is about 5.8 percent.' So there's a comparatively 'very high social and economic return' on 'fixing people, creating a base for future productivity and motivation for the society.'”
“Research posted at the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) in Atlanta confirms similarly huge benefits to society in medical terms. The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study, led by San Diego's Kaiser HMO and analyzed by CDC epidemiologists, indicated that the bodies and brains of children who live with the trauma of family violence, addiction, alcohol abuse, or homelessness are neurochemically changed long-term. The consequence is not just an increased likelihood of adult problems such as chronic anxiety, depression, and cognitive impairment, but physical disorders like cancer, heart disease, emphysema, obesity, chronic bronchitis, and diabetes...even when an individual's diet, exercise regimen, and other lifestyle choices have been healthy.”
(This is one of those stories I'd damn well rather not have read. Coming from a savagely dysfunctional family – my mother tried to murder me when I was five – I already have heart disease and suffer from seemingly incurable post-smoking obesity. Now this report adds the prospect of cancer – the one mode of death that because of its prolonged agony I find utterly terrifying.)
***
Capitalism's War on Working-Class Youth (a Michigan perspective): the state's GOPigs now want to force impoverished kids to suffer the (additional) humiliation of getting their clothing only from junk shops. “A small part of the DHS savings, about $200,000, would come from adjustments to the clothing allowance for foster children, or children of the working poor, of $79 for school clothes...children will still get close to that $79, but would be issued gift cards that can only be used at the Salvation Army, Goodwill or other thrift stores.”
From The Detroit News, with thanks to Common Dreams for the catch:
http://www.detnews.com/article/20110415/POLITICS02/104150367/Michigan-lawmakers-push-deeper-cuts
***
Why Do Capitalists So Despise Working-Class Youth? The short answer is the Wall Street parasites and the Big Business robber-barons fear the revolutionary potential of Working Class youth just as the Tsar feared the Russian proletariat.
Though none of the four prerequisites of revolution exist in today's United States – the Ruling Class has carefully structured our lives to make sure there is no solidarity-building ideology; no organization; no public access by which to nullify to the technologies of oppression; no possibility of foreign assistance – all of those deficits could be eliminated in the years ahead.
There is no question capitalism is already jeopardizing our species' survival. Opposition to the capitalist-inflicted apocalypse could thus become the bond for an aggressive socialist alliance throughout Latin America. Many Europeans meanwhile believe capitalist tyranny could trigger a new socialist revolution in Russia.
Or the Chinese Empire (which curiously and perhaps significantly remains officially Communist), might declare itself the savior of the world. China could utilize the money and power it has reaped from the capitalist global economy, reinvesting its enormous wealth in worldwide socialist revolution – a possibility underscored by a key principle of Sun Tzu, “all warfare is based on deception.”
Hence I cannot but wonder if the Chinese are merely pretending to embrace capitalism. Given Sun Tzu, what better means of defending against capitalism? More to the point, how better to avoid the fate that befell the Soviet Union?
(Apropos Sun Tzu, probably the most informative translation and commentary is the book by Samuel B. Griffith: Sun Tzu The Art of War, Oxford University Press, London: 1971.)
Meanwhile it is not enough to merely state the obvious, that the capitalists are seeking to zombify us all (and particularly Working Class youth) into the mindset of slavery. We need to know the details – and Henry Giroux has been exploring this topic in analytical detail for several years. His writing, though somewhat verbose – he desperately needs a competent editor – is nevertheless vital reading:
http://www.truthout.org/youth-suspect-society-coming-age-era-disposability/1304604010
*****
DIALOGUES
To date the most readable analysis of the Consummate Evil that is capitalism is entitled "Delusion and Denial Part I," a stunningly perceptive piece by Kristine Mattis made available through Common Dreams:
http://www.commondreams.org/view/2011/05/01-1
It prompted me to access its author's blog and respond as follows:
“Even if you do not do as I hope you will eventually do – trace capitalism to its toxic roots in the Abrahamic religions and ultimately in patriarchy itself – you have begun setting out the principles for a new and genuinely species-wide people's manifesto: something no one – especially not the authors of the Port Huron Statement – has been able to accomplish since Marx and Engels.”
http://www.rebelpleb.blogspot.com/
***
Facebook's brain-police function: “I'm not the least bit surprised to hear of this (rising) tide of Facebook deletions. FB not only deleted the specific essay but permanently severed the click-on link between FB and this blog when I posted my 27 April 2010 piece speculating the entire economic collapse was deliberately inflicted by the Ruling Class. (See 'Economic Collapse: Capitalist Death-Stroke to Hated Public Services?')...FB suppressed this work literally minutes after it went up, though several people saw what was happening and quickly re-posted it. But not even the (superb) tech support people at TypePad, my blog server, were able to restore my shortcut to FB. Eventually though I discovered I could still post links to my blog on FB, but I had to do so by the copy-and-paste method, not by merely clicking on an icon.”
“Not long after the 'Economic Collapse' incident, FB began playing games with my photographic portfolio, making specific images inaccessible. Significantly, the pictures so suppressed are illustrations of some of the extremes of urban poverty inflicted by capitalism.
“Finally FB let enough of my personal information out, my friends were under attack by phish-fraudsters, leaving me no choice but to terminate my FB membership forever. This of course resulted in a substantial decline in blog readership, which I am gradually making up via Twitter, though I remain enough unfamiliar with Twitter's processes – I find the associated instructions literally incomprehensible – I surely do not use it with any efficiency.”
Go here for the original anti-Facebook report and 40 additional comments (my remarks are near the end of the commentary thread):
http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2011/04/29-7
*****
MISCELLANY
Compensation for dereliction: last week I quoted Peter Gabriel's incomparable “Biko” – “once the flame begins to catch, the wind will blow it higher” – but I failed to provide a link to Gabriel's most stirring performance of the song. I heard this while I was still in the City, was in fact riding a cab from my Upper West Side apartment to my office at Madison and East 39th Street and realized the cabbie, an owner-driver, was listening to Gabriel's 1986 Amnesty International concert live via FM radio on a superb stereo system. I asked the driver to max out the volume, he did, and when the pipes in Gabriel's arrangement began to wail a moment later, it tugged at my soul with the gooseflesh intensity usually achieved only by the more ancient forms of traditional British folk music. Despite our ethnic differences – I of mostly Scots ancestry, the driver a newly-naturalized black South African – neither of us had dry eyes when we arrived at my destination.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iLg-8Jxi5aE
(Once again, we see how much – O how much – the late James Baldwin got right: even in the '80s, New York City truly was Another Country.)
LB/7 May 2011
-30-